也谈社科学报的现状与改革切入点——答尹玉吉先生

发布时间：2018-06-17 17:44

本文选题：学报 + 期刊体制改革　；参考：《清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版)》2011年04期

【摘要】：尹玉吉先生在其题为《论中国大学学报现状与改革切入点》的文章中,试图以对高校学报整体"业绩辉煌"的证明来笼统地否定改革的必要,以对"特色论"的批判来有针对性地否定学报专业化转型的必要,从而对17家教育部名刊工程综合性学报联合创办的"高校系列专业期刊"予以彻底否定。但由于尹先生并不懂得评价机构的基本规则,其所谓"系列权威数据"恰恰只能证明其论点不能成立;而他所做的"大学学报功能考察"、"学报特色反思"以及"中西方学术期刊比较",根本无视我国高等教育和科研事业的发展,显露出了胶柱鼓瑟般的偏执和片面;他所提出的"我国大学学报的出路应该从攸关其质量的审稿入手",不过是刻意规避高校期刊体制改革的虚晃一枪。笔者以为,改革的目标应该设定在科学合理的高校社科期刊体系的建立,这才是问题的关键。至于什么样的手段最合适,则应该放在这个目标下来考量,而"高校系列专业期刊"的创办正是学报同仁为合理的高校社科期刊体系的建立进行的有益探索。
[Abstract]:In his article entitled "on the present situation and Reform entry Point of Chinese University Journals", Mr. Yin Yuji tries to deny the necessity of reform in general terms by proving the "brilliant achievements" of the journals of colleges and universities as a whole. Based on the criticism of "characteristic theory", the necessity of professional transformation of journals is denied, and the "series of specialized journals of colleges and universities" jointly established by 17 famous journals of the Ministry of Education are denied thoroughly. However, since Mr Yin does not understand the basic rules of the evaluation body, his so-called "series of authoritative data" can only prove that his argument does not hold true; His "functional investigation of University Journals", "reflection on the characteristics of Journals" and "comparison of academic Journals between China and the West" have completely ignored the development of higher education and scientific research in our country, and have revealed the paranoid and one-sided nature of the rubber drum. He put forward that "the outlet of university journals in our country should begin with the review of manuscripts which are of vital importance to the quality of journals", which is only a deliberate attempt to avoid the falsehood of the reform of the periodical system in colleges and universities. The author thinks that the goal of the reform should be set up in the establishment of a scientific and reasonable social science periodical system in colleges and universities, which is the key to the problem. As to what kind of means is the most appropriate, we should put this goal under consideration, and the establishment of "the series of specialized journals in colleges and universities" is the beneficial exploration for the establishment of a reasonable system of social science periodicals in colleges and universities.
【作者单位】：《南京大学学报》编辑部;
【基金】：2009年教育部人文社会科学研究一般项目(09YJAZH043)
【分类号】：G237.5

【参考文献】