试论医疗过失司法鉴定文书

发布时间：2018-11-01 11:04

【摘要】：司法鉴定结论是案件审理的重要依据,司法鉴定文书作为鉴定结论的载体,倍受诉讼各方的关注,它必须反映鉴定过程以及鉴定结论如何形成,体现医疗过失鉴定的公正性和科学性。医疗过失司法鉴定文书既有普通司法鉴定文书的特点,在制作上应符合统一的司法鉴定文书格式,但又有独特之处,与医疗事故鉴定文书相比有明显区别。此外,目前各个司法鉴定机构的医疗过失司法鉴定文书在病历摘抄、分析论述、鉴定结果表述等方面存在不规范的现象,这种不规范不利于诉讼各方对鉴定结果的理解,从而也影响了案件的审判。从上述几个方面对医疗过失司法鉴定文书加以重视,有利于提升鉴定文书的规范性,增强鉴定结论的证明力,充分实现证据价值。
[Abstract]:The conclusion of judicial expertise is an important basis for the trial of cases. As the carrier of the conclusion, the document of judicial identification has attracted the attention of all parties to the lawsuit. It must reflect the process of identification and how to form the conclusion. Reflect the fairness and scientific nature of medical fault identification. The judicial identification document of medical negligence not only has the characteristics of the ordinary judicial identification document, but also has its unique features, which should be made in accordance with the uniform format of the judicial identification document, and it is obviously different from the medical malpractice identification document. In addition, at present, the medical negligence judicial identification documents of various judicial expertise institutions are not standardized in the aspects of medical record extraction, analysis and exposition, appraisal result expression, etc. This kind of nonstandard is not conducive to the parties' understanding of the appraisal result. This also affected the trial of the case. From the above several aspects to pay attention to the medical negligence judicial identification document, it is helpful to enhance the standardization of the identification document, enhance the proof power of the appraisal conclusion, and fully realize the value of the evidence.
【作者单位】：中国政法大学证据科学教育部重点实验室;
【基金】：教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目(06JZD0009)
【分类号】：D926;D918.9

【参考文献】