四重证据:知识的整合与立体释古

发布时间：2018-02-11 09:07

本文关键词： 多重证据法考古学傅斯年三重证据法学术方法新材料知识整合释古日本人类学立体　出处：《江苏行政学院学报》2010年06期 　论文类型：期刊论文

【摘要】：西学东渐以来,中西学术间的激荡与互动从未止息。伴随着国学的沉沦与复兴,一个亟待突破的命题日益凸显,这就是中西学术方法的融合、再造与创新。本期刊发的三篇文章即对此作出了有益的尝试。叶舒宪《四重证据:知识的整合与立体释古》继上世纪90年代中期的"三重证据法"之后,又提出"四重证据法"的命题,强调文史研究中文献之外的人类学、考古学材料的重要性,认为对非文字材料的自觉利用和多学科知识的整合,给国学的考据传统带来视野和方法的大变革。代云红《"媒介场"视域中的"多重证据法"》认为在"多重证据法"的结构框架中,存在着以文字符号为中心的书写媒介文化和以非文字符号为中心的口传及图像媒介文化,必须警惕"多重证据法"中的媒介霸权、符号暴力和文化意识形态。孟华《图像证据的符号学分析》从符号学角度研究图像与待证事实之间的真实关联度,讨论了两种图像理据:结构理据和意指理据。探索跨文化跨学科的知识整合与人文科学学术方法的创新正是上述三文价值之所在。
[Abstract]:Since the development of western learning to the east, the agitation and interaction between Chinese and Western scholars have never stopped. With the decline and revival of Chinese traditional culture, a proposition that needs to be broken through is increasingly prominent, that is, the integration of Chinese and Western academic methods. Reengineering and Innovation. The three articles published in this issue have made a beneficial attempt. Ye Shuxian, "Triple evidence: integration of knowledge and Three-dimensional interpretation of Ancient Times." after the Triple evidence Act of the middle of -10s, It also puts forward the proposition of "four-fold evidence law", emphasizes the importance of anthropological and archaeological materials other than the literature in the study of literary history, and holds that the conscious use of non-written materials and the integration of multidisciplinary knowledge, The tradition of textual research has brought great changes in the field of vision and methods. Dai Yun Hong < "multiple evidence Law" in the View of "Media Field" > thinks that it is in the framework of the structure of "multiple evidence Law". There exists writing media culture centered on character symbols and oral and image media culture centered on non-character symbols. Therefore, media hegemony in the multiple evidence Law must be guarded against. Symbolic violence and Cultural ideology. Meng Hua "semiotic Analysis of Image evidence" from the perspective of semiotics to study the true correlation between images and facts to be proved, This paper discusses two kinds of image motivation: structural motivation and implied motivation. Exploring cross-cultural and interdisciplinary knowledge integration and the innovation of the academic methods of humanities is the value of the above three texts.
【作者单位】：中国社会科学院文学研究所;
【分类号】：K06

【相似文献】