基于内容信息的中外图书情报学期刊互引关系对比研究

发布时间：2018-05-15 06:57

本文选题：期刊互引 + 社会网络分析　；参考：《曲阜师范大学》2017年硕士论文

【摘要】：期刊是学科发展到一定阶段的产物,它在传递信息、传播知识方面起到十分重要的作用。研究工作者所需的参考文献,一半以上来自期刊,期刊同时负责将最新的学术成果进行展示,以便学者交流。期刊之间的知识传递,离不开引用与被引用,期刊互引分析是期刊引证分析中的一种,它可以明确期刊之间的具体知识交流情况,展现期刊在互引过程中所处的地位等,为期刊评价、学科内部知识结构分析等提供新的视角。已有的期刊引用方法包括期刊耦合分析(Joural Coupling Analysis)、期刊共引分析(Joural Co-citation Analysis,简称JCA)、期刊互引(journal cross-citation Analysis)等。期刊耦合可以探测学科知识结构,可用于某一学科的知识聚类研究;期刊共引可以揭示核心期刊的贡献力,划分不同层面、不同方向的研究群体与主题结构探测;期刊互引则可以从宏观微观两个方面体现期刊间的知识相关性和学科互动性。然而,这些引用方法多从数据方面着手,鲜有加入期刊内容进行分析。因此本文在分析期刊互引的同时,引入内容分析法,将融入内容与未融入内容的期刊互引作对比分析,最后对中外图书情报学期刊互引做对比研究,可以看出中外图书情报领域期刊之间的知识交流过程以及不同期刊在知识交流中所起的作用。目前,国内外已有对期刊关系做过分析的研究,多集中在期刊评价、期刊引文和期刊类型上,本文着眼于期刊互引、社会网络分析和内容分析法三种方法对中外图书情报学期刊进行分析。本文以2014-2015年国外28种核心期刊和国内18种核心期刊为数据样本进行分析并绘制知识图谱,最后,对国内外的期刊互引情况作对比分析,为国内图书情报学期刊的发展寻找发展契机。首先从国外视角出发,利用社会网络分析中的有关指标对国外28种信息学类期刊的互引情况以及加入期刊主题词后的互引情况进行对比分析,得出以下结论:(1)与原有的互引分析方法对比发现,国外信息学期刊之间知识流动频繁,期刊在知识交流过程中承担不同角色,28种期刊基于内容联系在知识交流中承担知识源、知识桥梁和知识吸收库的任务。(2)其中,J AM SOC INF SCI TEC和MIS QUART是国外信息学领域中的核心期刊,在知识传递和知识输送中发挥重要作用;AM ECON REV在28种期刊中扮演知识桥梁的角色,对信息学期刊之间知识交流提供条件。其次,对国内18种图书情报学期刊的互引情况以及加入期刊主题词后的互引情况进行对比分析,得出以下结论:(1)国内18种图书情报学期刊的互引网络整体上联系紧密,知识交流频繁。(2)图书情报学期刊在知识交流中处于不同位置,承担不同角色,其中,加入主题词后更加凸显出中国图书馆学报是图书馆学中有重要影响的期刊,情报科学与情报杂志是情报学中有重要影响的期刊。本文共分为六章,第一章介绍研究背景、研究意义和国内外研究现状,引出本文的研究方法并指出创新之处。第二章从理论方面进行阐述,分别解释期刊互引、社会网络分析的相关指标和内容分析法的测度指标,为下文的实证研究打下基础。第三、四章通过对期刊互引的实证研究,说明融入内容的期刊互引分析方法的步骤,并在研究过程中,发现期刊互引分析存在的不足,并在第六章总结全文时指出。通过国内、国外两个视角,以期刊引文分析法和内容分析法相结合分析图书情报期刊互引网络,可以从理论上为分析图书情报学期刊提供新的方法与切入点,同时,在实践上能够更加清晰地展现国内外图书情报学期刊的发展研究现状,为期刊评价研究提供参考。
[Abstract]:Periodicals are the product of the development of the subject to a certain stage. It plays a very important role in transmitting information and spreading knowledge. More than half of the reference documents needed by the researchers are from periodicals, and periodicals are responsible for displaying the latest academic achievements so that scholars can deliver the flow. The transfer of knowledge among periodicals can not be separated from citation and citation. The mutual citation analysis of periodicals is one of the periodical citation analysis. It can clarify the specific knowledge exchange between periodicals, show the position of periodicals in the process of mutual citation, and provide a new perspective for the evaluation of periodicals and the analysis of the internal knowledge structure of the subject. The existing method of citation of periodicals includes Joural Coupling Ana Lysis), journal co citation analysis (Joural Co-citation Analysis (abbreviated as JCA), journal mutual citation (Journal cross-citation Analysis), etc.. Journal coupling can detect subject knowledge structure and can be used for knowledge clustering research in a certain subject. Journal co citation can reveal the contribution of core periodicals and divide research groups in different directions, and different directions. Subject structure detection; journal mutual citation can reflect the knowledge relevance and interdisciplinary interaction between the two aspects of the macro and micro aspects. However, these quotes often start from the data and rarely join the content of periodicals to analyze. In the end, a comparative study of the mutual citation between Chinese and foreign periodicals of Chinese and foreign books and information is compared. The process of knowledge exchange between Chinese and foreign periodicals in the field of Library and information and the role of different periodicals in the exchange of knowledge can be seen. At present, there has been an analysis of periodical relations at home and abroad, mostly in the evaluation of periodical evaluation. In the journal citation and the type of periodicals, this article focuses on the analysis of Chinese and foreign books and information journals in three ways: the mutual citation of periodicals, the social network analysis and the content analysis method. This paper analyzes and draws the knowledge atlas for the data samples from 28 core periodicals and 18 domestic core periodicals in 2014-2015 years. Finally, the periodicals at home and abroad are made. The situation of mutual citation is compared and analyzed in order to find the development opportunity for the development of domestic library and information science periodicals. First, from the foreign perspective, this paper makes a comparative analysis of the mutual citation situation of 28 Foreign Information Science Periodicals in foreign countries and the mutual citation after joining the subject words of periodicals, and draws the following conclusions: (1) the following conclusions are drawn. The method of mutual citation analysis shows that the knowledge flow between foreign information journals is frequent and the periodicals take different roles in the process of knowledge exchange. The 28 periodicals are based on the knowledge source, knowledge bridge and the task of knowledge absorption in the knowledge exchange. (2) J AM SOC INF SCI TEC and MIS QUART are the field of information science. The core periodicals play an important role in knowledge transmission and knowledge transmission; AM ECON REV plays the role of knowledge bridge in the 28 periodicals, and provides conditions for knowledge exchange among the periodicals of information science. Secondly, it compares and analyzes the mutual citation of the 18 kinds of books and Information Periodicals in China and the mutual citation after joining the subject words of the periodicals. The following conclusions are drawn: (1) the mutual citation network of the 18 kinds of books and information journals in China is closely linked and the knowledge exchange is frequent. (2) the periodicals of Library and information science are in different positions and take different roles in the knowledge exchange. Among them, the Chinese Library Journal is more prominent that the Journal of the Chinese library is an important periodical in the library science. The Journal of science and information is an important journal in information science. This article is divided into six chapters. The first chapter introduces the research background, the significance and the status of the research at home and abroad, leads to the research methods and points out the innovation. The second chapter expounds from the theoretical aspects, interprets the related indexes of the periodicals and the social network analysis respectively. The measure index of content analysis method lays the foundation for the empirical study of the following. The third, fourth chapter, through the empirical research on the mutual citation of periodicals, explains the steps of the mutual citation analysis method of the periodicals, and finds the shortcomings of the journal mutual citation analysis in the course of the study, and points out that in the sixth chapter, there are two foreign countries and foreign countries. In view of the combination of Journal Citation Analysis and content analysis, the paper analyzes the mutual citation network of books and information periodicals, which can theoretically provide new methods and breakthrough points for the analysis of the term books and information journals. At the same time, it can more clearly show the status of the research on the development of Library and information journals at home and abroad in practice, and provide the periodical evaluation and research. Reference resources.

【学位授予单位】：曲阜师范大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2017
【分类号】：G353.1

【参考文献】