法外“政治合法性”对司法过程的影响及其消除——以“李国和案”为例

发布时间：2018-01-21 00:16

本文关键词： 公共舆论政治合法性司法过程法治秩序　出处：《法商研究》2013年05期 　论文类型：期刊论文

【摘要】：公共舆论与司法之间的关系一直备受争议,在近年来的一些重大"舆情公案"之中表现得尤为明显。通过对"李国和案"的分析可以看出,虽然人们一直指陈"舆论干预司法"、"舆论审判"、"多数暴力"等弊害,但是舆论并未直接进入司法体系,而是通过输入政治运行系统并以法外"政治合法性"的路径和方式介入司法过程的。这种法外"政治合法性"的介入造成了诸多不良影响。公共舆论介入司法过程的特殊路径与不良后果,源于我国当下"政法化"的司法体制和长久以来形成的法学"意识形态"。因此,要采取各种措施消除法外"政治合法性"的不良影响,实现公共舆论与司法之间的良性互动和平衡关系。
[Abstract]:The relationship between public opinion and justice has always been controversial, especially in some major "public opinion cases" in recent years, through the analysis of "Li Guohe case" can be seen. Although people have always accused Chen of "interference by public opinion in the administration of justice", "judgment of public opinion", "majority violence" and other evils, public opinion has not directly entered the judicial system. It is by entering the system of political operation and intervening in the judicial process in the way and way of extra-legal "political legitimacy". This kind of extra-legal "political legitimacy" The intervention of public opinion has caused many adverse effects. The special path and adverse consequences of public opinion intervention in the judicial process. It stems from the current judicial system of "politicalization" in our country and the "ideology" of jurisprudence formed for a long time. Therefore, various measures should be taken to eliminate the negative influence of "political legitimacy" outside the law. Realize the benign interaction and balance between public opinion and judicature.
【作者单位】：华东政法大学法律学院;
【基金】：国家社会科学基金资助项目(06BFX002)
【分类号】：D926.2;G206
【正文快照】： 当下我国之所以遇到公共舆论与司法之间的巨大张力问题,一方面是因为我国正处于社会转型期,各种利益和社会矛盾积聚并通过(包括司法在内的)各种形式表现出来;另一方面是因为我国的司法发挥着并非如有的国家那种三权分立体制下司法的角色和功能,而是处于一种有中国特色的“政

【参考文献】