论垄断违法性的实质认定

发布时间：2018-04-02 14:40

本文选题：垄断违法性　切入点：实质认定　出处：《学术交流》2015年06期

【摘要】：垄断违法性实质认定是从垄断的本质这个问题引申出来的,它意在回答为什么要限制垄断,将其规定为非法的问题。从我国反垄断司法实践看,将事实判断与形式规范结合认定垄断违法性在我国司法实践中一直占据主导地位,很少根据反垄断法的价值规范对垄断违法性作实质认定。垄断违法性的形式认定与实质认定呈分立状态、垄断违法性实质认定被虚置,不仅很难保证反垄断裁决的自洽性与合理性,也不利于提升反垄断法的质量及其延展性。因此,应当从理论上诠释垄断违法性实质认定的意涵,厘清垄断违法性实质认定的标准及其适用规则;应当检讨我国垄断违法性认定的实践运行方法与逻辑,从完善中国反垄断法的价值构造、反垄断案例指导制度与凝聚垄断违法性实质认定与形式认定相统一的共识等途径,促进我国垄断违法性认定在理论认知与制度规范上的进阶。
[Abstract]:The essence of illegal monopoly is derived from the essence of monopoly. It is intended to answer the question of why to restrict monopoly and make it illegal.From the point of view of our country's anti-monopoly judicial practice, the combination of factual judgment and formal norms has always occupied a dominant position in the judicial practice of our country, and few of them have made substantial determination of monopoly illegality according to the value norms of anti-monopoly law.The form and substance of monopoly illegality are in a separate state, but it is not only difficult to guarantee the self-consistency and rationality of anti-monopoly ruling, but also unfavorable to improving the quality and extensibility of anti-monopoly law, which is not only difficult to guarantee the self-consistency and reasonableness of anti-monopoly adjudication, but also unfavorable to the improvement of the quality and extensibility of anti-monopoly law.Therefore, it is necessary to interpret the meaning of illegal nature of monopoly in theory, clarify the standards and applicable rules of the determination of illegal nature of monopoly, and review the practical operation methods and logic of illegal nature of monopoly in China.By perfecting the value structure of China's anti-monopoly law, guiding the system of anti-monopoly cases and condense the consensus that the essence and form of illegal monopoly are United, we can promote the progress of the recognition of monopoly illegality in the theoretical cognition and system norm in our country.
【作者单位】：贵州师范大学法学院;
【基金】：国家软科学研究计划重大公开招标项目“国有资产管理对科技成果转化的影响研究”(2013GXS4D122)
【分类号】：D922.294

【参考文献】