对优秀刑事裁判文书成立要素的探讨

发布时间：2018-02-09 08:56

本文关键词： 刑事裁判文书评价参数优秀形式实质　出处：《山东大学》2017年硕士论文　论文类型：学位论文

【摘要】：裁判文书是司法公正的最终载体,有利于保证国家法律的实施。裁判文书能反映法官的综合素质和办案质量,并且是扩大法制宣传的重要材料。但是在很长一段时间里,裁判文书在法律实务、法学教育及法学研究中都没有受到应有的重视。如今伴随着对裁判文书重视度的提高,相关研究也增多,但是多是研究裁判文书的语言、公开或者说理单个方面,缺乏综合性和全面性。此外,实践中裁判文书存在很多问题,质量参差不齐,损害了司法的公信力。司法改革的不断深入,为刑事裁判文书质量的提高提出了迫切要求,也提供了良好的环境。鉴于刑事案件的特殊性及刑事裁判的重要性,本文主要围绕刑事裁判文书如何做到优秀来做探讨。对于这个问题的探讨既是一个理论问题,又是一个实践问题。本文以刑事裁判文书的改进情况以及重要价值为开端,强调了优秀刑事裁判文书的重要性,进而介绍刑事裁判文书存在的问题,然后引出优秀刑事裁判文书的标准及评价参数,后面着重分析优秀刑事裁判文书的成立要素并提出建议,为刑事裁判文书的制作及其改革提供有价值的参考。
[Abstract]:Judicial documents are the ultimate carrier of judicial justice, which is conducive to ensuring the implementation of national laws. They can reflect the comprehensive quality of judges and the quality of handling cases, and are important materials for expanding the publicity of the legal system. However, in a long period of time, the judicial documents can reflect the comprehensive quality of judges and the quality of handling cases. Judicial documents have not received the due attention in legal practice, legal education and legal research. Nowadays, with the increase of attention to adjudicative documents, the relevant studies are also increasing, but most of them are the language of the study of adjudicative documents. In addition, in practice, there are many problems in the judicial documents, the quality of which is uneven, which has damaged the credibility of the administration of justice, and the deepening of the judicial reform. It also provides a good environment for the improvement of the quality of criminal adjudicative documents. In view of the particularity of criminal cases and the importance of criminal adjudication, This paper mainly focuses on how to achieve excellence in criminal adjudicative documents. The discussion of this problem is not only a theoretical problem but also a practical one. This paper begins with the improvement of criminal adjudicative documents and its important value. This paper emphasizes the importance of excellent criminal adjudicative documents, and then introduces the problems existing in criminal adjudicative documents, and then leads to the standards and evaluation parameters of excellent criminal adjudicative documents. In the end, the author analyzes the essential elements of the excellent criminal adjudicative documents and puts forward some suggestions, which can provide valuable reference for the making and reform of criminal adjudicative documents.
【学位授予单位】：山东大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2017
【分类号】：D926.13

【相似文献】