冤狱追责虚化势必纵容错案复发——今日呼格案与昔日杨乃武案比较与反省
发布时间：2019-03-16 14:54
【摘要】：冤假错案追责是司法公正的重要标志。真实严厉追责有利于未来减少冤狱,虚化搪塞追责则可能鼓励制造更多冤狱。内蒙古呼格冤案,在冤杀无辜这一最严重恶果经再审确认之后,在举国上下多年千夫所指、千呼万唤的巨大压力下,对冤案制造人员的追责仍仅仅以党纪政纪处分了事。这一结果大出国人意料,引起相当质疑,让人不禁联想起清末杨乃武冤案。古今比较可能让我们更加清楚这一结果的荒唐:今日就枉杀无辜的最重冤案之追责,其力度竞远不及百余年前仅误判死罪(尚未执行,仅关押3年)的冤案之追责。冤狱追责的虚化敷衍,不仅使司法公信力再次受损,更可能解除冤狱制造者的后顾之忧,客观上激励未来冤狱制造。
[Abstract]:Accountability for wrongs and wrongs is an important symbol of judicial justice. True and severe retribution is conducive to reducing the number of grievances in the future, while false evading may encourage the creation of more grievances. After the retrial of the most serious evil result of killing innocent people in Hoga case in Inner Mongolia, under the enormous pressure of thousands of references and thousands of calls from all over the country, the accountability of the unjust case-makers is still done only by the party discipline and the government discipline. The result was unexpected, causing considerable doubt, reminiscent of Yang Naiwu's grievance at the end of the Qing Dynasty. The antiquity and modern comparison may make us more aware of the absurdity of this outcome: today's accountability for the most serious cases of killing innocent people is far less severe than that for which the death penalty (which has not yet been executed and only three years in detention) was wrongly convicted more than a hundred years ago. The falsification of the prosecution of the unjust prison not only damages the judicial credibility once again, but also relieves the worries of the unjust prison maker, and objectively encourages the future unjust prison to create.
【作者单位】： 中央民族大学法学院;
【基金】：作者主持的国家社科基金青年项目《法治“德礼”重建与“礼法合治”传统治理资源的创造性发展研究》(16CFX007)阶段性成果
【分类号】：D925.2
本文编号：2441592
[Abstract]:Accountability for wrongs and wrongs is an important symbol of judicial justice. True and severe retribution is conducive to reducing the number of grievances in the future, while false evading may encourage the creation of more grievances. After the retrial of the most serious evil result of killing innocent people in Hoga case in Inner Mongolia, under the enormous pressure of thousands of references and thousands of calls from all over the country, the accountability of the unjust case-makers is still done only by the party discipline and the government discipline. The result was unexpected, causing considerable doubt, reminiscent of Yang Naiwu's grievance at the end of the Qing Dynasty. The antiquity and modern comparison may make us more aware of the absurdity of this outcome: today's accountability for the most serious cases of killing innocent people is far less severe than that for which the death penalty (which has not yet been executed and only three years in detention) was wrongly convicted more than a hundred years ago. The falsification of the prosecution of the unjust prison not only damages the judicial credibility once again, but also relieves the worries of the unjust prison maker, and objectively encourages the future unjust prison to create.
【作者单位】： 中央民族大学法学院;
【基金】：作者主持的国家社科基金青年项目《法治“德礼”重建与“礼法合治”传统治理资源的创造性发展研究》(16CFX007)阶段性成果
【分类号】：D925.2
【相似文献】
相关期刊论文 前3条
1 张建伟;;从呼格吉勒图案看刑事诉讼中诱供之害[J];刑事司法论坛;2011年00期
2 魏义民,刘宏章,图门;牧民心中的丰碑——追记阿左旗图克木苏木西尼乌素嘎查达呼格吉勒图[J];内蒙古宣传;2002年09期
3 ;[J];;年期
相关重要报纸文章 前7条
1 宁新春;让公平正义之光照进呼格吉勒图案[N];新华每日电讯;2014年
2 刘慧蕾;呼格吉乐基金助牧民圆了小康梦[N];中国黄金报;2013年
3 早报记者 简光洲;李三仁夫妇为儿申冤记[N];东方早报;2011年
4 记者 史万森 张驰;内蒙古高院决定再审呼格吉勒图案[N];法制日报;2014年
5 李斌;靠法治昭雪冤案[N];中国纪检监察报;2014年
6 田力;令人心痛的冤案为何频现[N];中国商报;2011年
7 “新华视点”记者 张丽娜 罗沙 徐xY;从被判死刑到再审，，两个九年里发生了什么[N];新华每日电讯;2014年
相关硕士学位论文 前2条
1 高海永;呼格吉勒图案对我国刑事再审启动的启示[D];兰州大学;2015年
2 张赛寒;呼格吉夫蒙古族儿童歌曲创作研究[D];内蒙古师范大学;2014年
本文编号：2441592
本文链接：https://www.wllwen.com/falvlunwen/susongfa/2441592.html
