承继共犯的成立:肯定说的新生

发布时间：2018-04-12 16:19

本文选题：承继共犯肯定说 + 承继共犯否定说　；参考：《东方法学》2015年05期

【摘要】：承继共犯的成立问题主要是聚焦于承继共同正犯予以讨论的。在日本,承继共犯的成立问题存在承继共犯肯定说、承继共犯否定说与承继共犯中间说的分歧,而在我国当下则主要是承继共犯肯定说与承继共犯中间说的分歧。承继共犯否定说得到国内个别学者的极力推崇。承继共犯否定说的主要立论依据是"因果责任论"和"责任主义",但其却在各种行为类型中存在着这样或那样的问题。而这些问题在暴露出承继共犯否定说"自相矛盾"的同时,集中地说明着该说所犯的无视共同犯罪事实的"分割评价"错误,从而违背罪刑法定原则和罪刑均衡原则,以至于走向"责任主义"的反面。承继共犯肯定说完全可以在直面和恰当把握"因果性"问题和"责任主义"包括"部分实行全部责任"原则中,通过妥善地解决承继共犯包括承继共同正犯所对应的实践问题而获得"新生"。
[Abstract]:The establishment of succession accomplice mainly focuses on the discussion of succession accomplice.In Japan, there are differences between the theory of inheritance accomplice affirmation, the negation of succession accomplice and the succession accomplice, but in our country, it is mainly the difference between the affirmation of inheriting accomplice and the theory of succession accomplice.The negation of inheriting accomplice can be highly respected by individual scholars in China.The main theoretical basis of the negation of accomplice is "causality liability theory" and "responsibility doctrine", but there are some problems in all kinds of behavior types.These problems, while exposing the "self-contradiction" of the negation theory of inheriting accomplices, at the same time, at the same time, concentrate on explaining the "split evaluation" errors which ignore the facts of common crimes committed by the theory, thus violating the principle of legality of a crime and the principle of balance between the punishment and the crime.Towards the opposite of "responsibility doctrine".Succession accomplice is certain that it is perfectly possible to face and properly grasp the issue of "causality" and "responsibilism", including the principle of "partial implementation of full responsibility",A new life can be obtained by properly solving the practical problems of inheriting accomplices, including inheriting joint principal offenders.
【作者单位】：扬州大学法学院;
【分类号】：D914

【参考文献】