麦考密克法律论证理论视角下的辩护权

发布时间：2018-01-29 01:01

本文关键词： 辩护权法律实证主义法律论证审判为中心　出处：《国家检察官学院学报》2017年05期 　论文类型：期刊论文

【摘要】：根据麦考密克法律论证理论,辩护人在法庭上陈述和建构案件事实能够为法官提供备选的演绎规则,从而推进司法裁判程序。该辩护行为及其事实性权威证成了辩护权,并形式化为法律条文,开示辩护权背后的社会压力。以此讨论辩护权的中国样态,关注法律条文之间的内在张力,描述辩护权救济渠道不畅、审辩冲突加剧等情形,揭示辩护权在事实与规范之间的冲突。借助外部性反思视角,评析我国刑事诉讼格局对辩护权运行的影响,最终明确辩护权的有效落实仰赖以审判为中心、控辩地位平等、充分尊重权利的法律论辩。
[Abstract]:According to McCormick's theory of legal argumentation, defenders can provide alternative deductive rules for judges by stating and constructing facts in court. In order to promote the judicial adjudication procedure, the defense act and its factual authority has become the right of defense, and formalized as a legal provision, revealing the social pressure behind the right to defense, so as to discuss the Chinese model of the right of defense. Pay attention to the internal tension between the legal provisions, describe the remedy channel of the right of defense is not smooth, the conflict of trial and debate is intensified, and reveal the conflict between the fact and the norm of the right of defense, with the help of the perspective of external reflection. This paper comments on the influence of the pattern of criminal procedure on the operation of the right of defense, and finally makes it clear that the effective implementation of the right of defense depends on the legal argument that the trial is the center, the status of prosecution and defense is equal, and the rights are fully respected.
【作者单位】：上海交通大学凯原法学院;
【分类号】：D925.2
【正文快照】： 法律实证主义如何通过法律的概念分析和法律论证说明社会中人权的基本立场?法律概念凝聚着社会秩序的事实行动和社会价值取向,进而营造特有的社会秩序;在法律概念规范分析上展开的法律论证,能在具体的社会环境与现实语境下呈现出社会的基本立场,揭示人类尊严与良善生活方式的

【相似文献】