论我国仲裁裁决不予执行制度的废除

发布时间：2019-06-02 05:55

【摘要】：仲裁(本文特指我国国内民商事仲裁)成为市场经济条件下一种重要的解决民商事纠纷的诉讼替代方式,具有一裁终决、程序简单便捷等优点,越来越受到人们的青睐。我国国内仲裁裁决的司法监督制度目前存在撤销和不予执行两种程序并存的局面,其中不予执行制度存在诸多弊端,而且已经严重偏离国际上国内仲裁裁决只存在仲裁裁决撤销的制度的常态。本文首先从我国仲裁裁决不予执行制度的历史和现状出发,分析了该制度的立法现状和运行现状,从而得出了该制度的弊端,即：损害了仲裁制度的效率价值；降低了司法监督的效益；打击了人们追求正义的决心；偏离了国际惯例。随后,本文表明了应该废除我国仲裁裁决不予执行制度的观点,阐述了对“存续派”的反驳以及废除该制度的必要性及可行性,其中必要性包括理论上的必要性及实践上的必要性。最后,本文提出了完善仲裁裁决不予执行制度的构想。
[Abstract]:Arbitration (this paper refers specifically to domestic civil and commercial arbitration) has become an important alternative way to solve civil and commercial disputes under the condition of market economy. It has the advantages of final decision, simple and convenient procedure, and is more and more favored by people. At present, there are two kinds of procedures coexisting in the judicial supervision system of domestic arbitral award in our country, in which there are many drawbacks in the system of non-execution. And has seriously deviated from the international and domestic arbitration award only exists the arbitration award annulment system normal. First of all, based on the history and present situation of the system of non-enforcement of arbitral awards in our country, this paper analyzes the present situation of legislation and operation of the system, and thus obtains the disadvantages of the system, that is, it damages the efficiency value of the arbitration system; Reduced the efficiency of judicial supervision; dealt a blow to people's determination to pursue justice; deviated from international practice. Then, this paper shows the viewpoint that the system of non-enforcement of arbitral awards in our country should be abolished, and expounds the rebuttal of the "survival school" and the necessity and feasibility of abolishing the system. Among them, the necessity includes the necessity in theory and the necessity in practice. Finally, this paper puts forward the idea of perfecting the system of non-execution of arbitral award.
【学位授予单位】：湘潭大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2014
【分类号】：D925.7

【相似文献】