法秩序的统一性与违法判断的相对性

发布时间：2018-01-26 01:47

本文关键词： 法秩序的统一一般违法行为类型刑罚的合目的性　出处：《法学家》2016年03期 　论文类型：期刊论文

【摘要】：法秩序的统一是合目的性的统一,只要不损害法之目的的统一性,规范矛盾便可以被容许。一般违法的概念应当被承认,它统合各个法领域中的具体违法概念,适用于规范的行为类型。严格的违法一元论和形式违法论密切相关,排除了实质违法论的适用,不具有合理性。虽然一般违法的概念适用于全部行为类型,但刑法中进行一般违法判断的行为类型与其他部门法并不完全一致,刑法上的违法性判断不依赖于前置法;将法益侵害的量作为刑事违法性的认定要素符合违法的本质,是刑罚合目的性在违法性中的体现。因此,在一般违法的前提下,刑事违法的判断具有相对性。
[Abstract]:The unity of the legal order is the unity of purpose. As long as the unity of the purpose of the law is not damaged, the normative contradiction can be allowed. The general concept of illegal should be recognized, and it integrates the specific illegal concepts in various fields of law. Strictly illegal monism and formal illegality are closely related, excluding the application of substantive illegality, and not reasonable. Although the general concept of illegal is applicable to all types of behavior. However, the types of behavior of general illegal judgment in criminal law are not completely consistent with other branch laws, and the judgment of illegality in criminal law does not depend on the pre-law; Taking the amount of infringement of legal interests as the essential element of criminal illegality accords with the essence of illegality, and is the embodiment of the purposeful nature of punishment in illegality. Therefore, under the premise of general violation of law, the judgment of criminal violation is relative.
【作者单位】：中国人民大学刑事法律科学研究中心;
【分类号】：D914
【正文快照】： 法律是规范公民行为、调整社会生活最重要的手段,各个法领域之间各有分工,相互配合,形成了较为稳定的法律秩序,而国家即是这一法律秩序的人格化体现。#174;如果法律内部出现难以容忍的矛盾,不仅无法为公民生活提供行为规范,还会对法律体系本身造成结构性破坏。因此,法秩序的

【参考文献】