仇恨型故意杀人案件死刑裁量反思——贾敬龙案量刑妥当性多维分析

发布时间：2018-05-12 00:30

本文选题：贾敬龙案 + 民间矛盾　；参考：《吉林大学社会科学学报》2017年03期

【摘要】：贾敬龙案涉及尖锐复杂的民间矛盾,属于由矛盾激化所引发的仇恨型故意杀人案件。民间矛盾激化所致仇恨型故意杀人案件往往情有可悯,对之是否适用死刑立即执行应当审慎、全面地考察。虽然该案判决符合三段论的形式逻辑,但通过图尔敏论证模型进行实质分析后,可以看出司法机关对该案司法裁判的论证重心在于其"可杀"之处,而对"可不杀"之情节考察不足,显然论证并不全面。而司法机关对此案的裁判与以往实践中所采取的死刑司法控制政策以及最高法院指导性案例,所持立场不一致,缺乏融贯性。同时,对贾敬龙案做出死刑立即执行的判决,也缺乏刑罚沟通主义精神。
[Abstract]:Jia Jing - long ' s case involves sharp and complex folk contradictions , and belongs to the hate - type intentional homicide caused by the contradiction . But after the analysis of the case , it can be seen that the judicial authority ' s argument about the judicial decision of the case lies in its " killing " , and it is not comprehensive . However , the judicial organ ' s judgment on the case is not comprehensive . At the same time , the judicial organ ' s judgment on the case is inconsistent with the judicial control policy of the death penalty and the guidance of the Supreme Court .

【作者单位】：吉林大学法学院;
【分类号】：D924.13

【相似文献】