扰乱医疗秩序罪的立法研究

发布时间：2018-07-09 09:28

本文选题：扰乱医疗秩序罪 + 立法研究　；参考：《甘肃政法学院》2017年硕士论文

【摘要】：2015年11月1日,《刑法修正案(九)》第31条将聚众扰乱医疗秩序的行为纳入刑法的规制范畴,由聚众扰乱社会秩序罪进行规制调整。然而笔者认为这个罪名对于犯罪构成要件的涵盖并不全面,因此本文就以近年来涉医违法犯罪事件的频发为背景,选取三起典型案例进行对比分析,探讨单独设立“扰乱医疗秩序罪”并在“扰乱医疗秩序罪”中设置转化犯的立法建议。同时,提出进一步完善与扰乱医疗秩序行为相关的民事、行政法律法规,最终逐步形成民事处罚、行政处罚与刑法处罚相衔接的意见。本文分为以下三个部分,具体内容如下:第一部分,典型案例。这部分共两节,第一节是典型案例简介,第二节是典型案例分析。典型案例简介一节选取了三起涉医违法犯罪案件,通过对比三起案例,分析了聚众扰乱社会秩序罪与故意杀人罪、聚众扰乱社会秩序罪与寻衅滋事罪的区别,最后总结聚众扰乱社会秩序罪中扰乱医疗秩序行为的特征。第二部分,扰乱医疗秩序行为的规制现状。这部分从我国和国外两个方面展开叙述,通过对比分析我国和国外对于该行为的规制现状,探求借鉴我国解决涉医违法犯罪的路径。第三部分,扰乱医疗秩序罪的立法构想。这部分共三节,第一节揭示扰乱医疗秩序行为的危害,第二节分析聚众扰乱社会秩序罪的缺陷,第三节提出扰乱医疗秩序罪的立法建议。
[Abstract]:On November 1, 2015, Article 31 of the Criminal Law Amendment (9) brought the behavior of mass disturbance of medical order into the scope of the criminal law, which was regulated by the crime of mass disturbing the social order. However, the author thinks that this crime does not cover all the elements of the crime, so this paper selects three typical cases for comparative analysis based on the frequent occurrence of crimes involving medical treatment in recent years. This paper probes into the legislative suggestion of establishing the crime of disturbing medical order separately and setting up the crime of transforming crime in the crime of disturbing medical order. At the same time, the author puts forward some suggestions on how to further perfect the civil and administrative laws and regulations related to the behavior of disturbing medical order, and finally form the civil punishment gradually, and the administrative punishment and the criminal law punishment should be linked up with each other. This article is divided into the following three parts, the specific contents are as follows: the first part, typical cases. This part has two sections, the first section is a typical case profile, the second section is a typical case analysis. In the section of typical case brief, three cases involving doctors are selected. By comparing three cases, the paper analyzes the difference between the crime of disturbing the public order and the crime of manslaughter, the crime of disturbing the public order and the crime of provoking trouble. Finally, it summarizes the characteristics of the behavior of disturbing medical order in the crime of mass disturbance of social order. The second part, the regulation present situation of disturbing medical order behavior. This part narrates from two aspects of our country and abroad, through the contrast analysis our country and the foreign to this behavior regulation present situation, seeks to draw lessons from our country to solve the medical treatment illegal crime path. The third part, the legislation conception of the crime of disturbing the medical order. This part has three sections, the first section reveals the harm of disturbing medical order behavior, the second section analyzes the defects of the crime of disturbing the public order, the third section puts forward the legislative suggestions of the crime of disturbing the medical order.
【学位授予单位】：甘肃政法学院
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2017
【分类号】：D924.3

【相似文献】