河南省自然科学期刊学术影响力评价指标体系的构建与应用

发布时间：2018-04-17 02:16

本文选题：自然科学期刊 + 学术影响力　；参考：《郑州大学》2017年硕士论文

【摘要】：目的构建自然科学期刊学术影响力评价指标体系,确立各级指标的权重,为自然科学期刊学术质量的评价提供量化依据。运用构建的评价指标体系对河南省教育厅主管的自然科学期刊的学术影响力进行定量评价,为政府部门优选期刊和制定期刊发展政策提供科学依据评选提供借鉴。方法采用文献分析法、小组讨论法、专家咨询法(Delphi法)确立评价指标体系框架。运用层次分析法确定各级指标的权重。搜集各期刊相关数据,采用TOPSIS法、秩和比(Rank Sum Ratio,RSR)法以及二者模糊联合法对河南省教育厅主管的19种自然科学期刊学术影响力进行综合评价。结果1.建立了自然科学期刊学术影响力评价指标体系,以稿源特征指标、引文指标、收录指标以及网络传播指标为一级指标,在此基础上,建立包含15个二级指标的指标体系。2.Delphi法结果:(1)专家积极系数:进行了两轮函询,第一轮专家积极系数为95%。第二轮专家积极系数为89.5%。(2)指标体系的确定第一轮专家咨询后,删除一级指标“稿源特征指标”下的二级指标“载文量”和“创刊年限”,增加一级指标“引文指标”下的二级指标“学科影响指标”。最终确定的4个一级指标和15个二级指标,专家意见达成一致。(3)一级指标“稿源特征指标”、“引文指标”、“收录指标”和“网络传播指标”权重分别为10.7%、53.2%、17.5%、18.7%。二级指标中权重最大的三个指标分别为“影响因子”(15.2%)、“他被引率”(12.5%)和“国外数据库收录数”(11.9%)。3.19种自然科学期刊学术影响力综合评价:三种方法排序较靠前的五个期刊为郑州大学学报(医学版)、河南科技大学(自然科学版)、郑州大学学报(工学版)、河南工业大学学报(自然科学版)、河南师范大学学报(自然科学版)。4.14种综合科学技术类期刊学术影响力综合评价:三种方法排序较靠前的三个期刊为郑州大学学报(工学版)、河南科技大学(自然科学版)、河南工业大学学报(自然科学版)。5.4种医学类期刊学术影响力综合评价:三种方法排序较靠前的三个期刊为郑州大学学报(医学版)、河南外科学杂志、河南大学学报医学版。结论1.采用文献分析法、小组讨论法、专家咨询法和层次分析法构建了一套有4个一级指标和15个二级指标组成的自然科学期刊学术影响力评价指标体系。指标体系构建过程中,专家积极性高,专家代表性强,结果可信度高,构建过程严谨,指标体系各层符合逻辑,一致性较好。2.采用TOPSIS法、秩和比法以及二者加权模糊联合法对19种期刊,依据构建的自然科学期刊学术影响力综合评价体系进行综合评价,客观地对19种期刊进行定量排序,直观显示出其优劣顺序,为期刊管理部门对于期刊的选优以及优化提供科学依据。
[Abstract]:Objective to establish the evaluation index system of the academic influence of natural science periodicals, to establish the weight of the indexes at all levels, and to provide a quantitative basis for the evaluation of the academic quality of natural science periodicals.The evaluation index system is used to quantitatively evaluate the academic influence of the natural science periodicals in charge of the Department of Education in Henan Province, which provides a reference for the government departments to select the best periodicals and to formulate the periodical development policy.Methods document analysis, group discussion and expert consultation were used to establish the framework of evaluation index system.Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) is used to determine the weight of indexes at all levels.The relevant data of various journals were collected, and the academic influence of 19 natural science journals in Henan Province was evaluated comprehensively by TOPSIS method, Rank Sum Ratio RSR method and fuzzy combination method.Result 1.This paper establishes the evaluation index system of the academic influence of natural science periodicals, taking the characteristic index of manuscript source, the index of citation, the index of inclusion and the index of network communication as the first class index, on the basis of which,The result of Delphi method is: the expert positive coefficient: two rounds of letter inquiry, the first round expert positive coefficient is 95.The second round of experts' positive coefficient is 89.5.) after the first round of expert consultation, the second-class indexes under "manuscript source characteristic index" and "the number of articles published" and "the founding years" are deleted.Add the second class index, subject impact index, under the first class index, citation index.Among the 4 primary indexes and 15 second class indexes, the expert opinion reached an agreement. 3) the first class index "characteristic index of manuscript source", "citation index", "index of inclusion" and "index of network communication" were 10.7 / 53.2and 17.5and 18.7respectively.The three indexes with the largest weight in the secondary index are "influence factor" (15.2g), "his citation rate" (12.5b) and "number of foreign databases" (11.9 / 3.19 kinds of natural science journals' academic influence).The five journals are Journal of Zhengzhou University (Medical Edition), Henan University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition), Journal of Zhengzhou University (Engineering Edition), Journal of Henan University of Technology (Natural Science Edition), Journal of Henan normal University (Natural Science Edition).Comprehensive Evaluation of academic influence of Comprehensive Science and Technology Journals: the three journals ranked by three methods are Journal of Zhengzhou University (Engineering Edition), Henan University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition), Journal of Henan University of Technology (Nature)Comprehensive Evaluation of academic influence of Medical Journals in Science Edition: the three journals ranked by three methods are Journal of Zhengzhou University (Medical Edition, Henan Journal of surgery),Journal of Henan University Medical Edition.Conclusion 1.By using the methods of literature analysis, group discussion, expert consultation and analytic hierarchy process, a set of evaluation index system of academic influence of natural science periodicals is established, which consists of 4 primary indexes and 15 secondary indexes.In the process of index system construction, the experts are highly motivated, experts are representative, the results are reliable, the construction process is rigorous, and all levels of the index system accord with logic, and the consistency is good. 2.Using TOPSIS method, rank sum ratio method and weighted fuzzy combination method, 19 journals were evaluated synthetically according to the comprehensive evaluation system of the academic influence of natural science journals, and 19 journals were objectively ranked quantitatively.The order of its advantages and disadvantages is shown intuitively, which provides the scientific basis for the periodical management department to select and optimize the periodicals.
【学位授予单位】：郑州大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2017
【分类号】：G237.5;G353.1

【相似文献】