网络链接中的侵犯版权问题研究

发布时间：2018-04-27 16:42

本文选题：网络链接 + 版权侵权　；参考：《中国政法大学》2010年硕士论文

【摘要】： 网络链接是互联网的基本技术,是人类自由共享理想实现的手段之一。网络技术的发展带来诸多社会问题,版权侵权就是其中之一。纵观近年来发生的网络案件,网络链接引起的版权侵权纠纷越来越受到人们的关注。对于该问题,学界已经做了一些研究,主要是从传统版权法的角度,通过对链接技术原理的分析,判断链接是否侵犯版权。个中分析不免有脱离网络时代的社会现实之嫌,而且单纯从法律的角度看待网络世界出现的问题,往往会得出偏颇的结论。笔者在本文中试图从版权法的精神实质、网络的现实情况以及伦理道德三个角度对链接引起的版权侵权问题做一立体考察。本文共分三部分。第一章归纳了近年来链接引起的版权侵权纠纷。通过归纳可以发现,此类纠纷主要集中在设置链接行为本身是否侵犯版权,链接设置者是否应为被链接的第三方网页的内容负责两个问题上。第二章主要是从法律角度分析链接引起的版权侵权纠纷。在本章的第一部分,笔者首先总结了学者对设置连接行为是否直接侵犯版权的研究成果,然后以版权法如何应对传播技术造成的挑战为线索,厘清版权法的实质精神。以此为基础,笔者对链接是否直接侵犯版权提出了自己的看法。本章的第二部分是对链接引起的帮助性侵权纠纷的分析。笔者首先总结了我国规制帮助性侵权的相关法律、法规和司法解释。并结合相关案例,探讨了我国法院是如何认定设置链接是否构成帮助性侵权的。以此为基础,笔者分析了帮助性侵权规则存在的缺陷,并探讨了以商业模式解决此类问题的可行性。正如人类社会不仅需要法律,还需要其他社会规范的规制一样,网络世界出现的问题同样需要用多种方式才能真正解决。最后一章中,笔者试图从伦理道德的角度对链接引起的版权侵权问题进行分析,希望借助人类社会另一种重要的规范形式更好地化解此类复杂矛盾。
[Abstract]:Network link is the basic technology of the Internet and one of the means to realize the ideal free sharing of human beings. The development of network technology brings many social problems, copyright infringement is one of them. In recent years, people pay more and more attention to copyright infringement disputes caused by network links. For this problem, scholars have done some research, mainly from the point of view of traditional copyright law, through the analysis of the principle of link technology, to determine whether the link infringes copyright. It is inevitable that the analysis is divorced from the social reality of the network age, and the problems in the network world can be viewed only from the angle of law, which often leads to biased conclusions. In this paper, the author tries to make a three-dimensional study of copyright infringement caused by link from the aspects of the spiritual essence of copyright law, the reality of the network and the ethics and morality. This paper is divided into three parts. The first chapter summarizes the copyright infringement disputes caused by links in recent years. It can be found that this kind of dispute mainly focuses on whether the link itself infringes copyright and whether the linker should be responsible for the content of the linked third party web page. The second chapter mainly analyzes the copyright infringement dispute caused by link from the angle of law. In the first part of this chapter, the author first summarizes the scholars' research results on whether the establishment of connection behavior directly infringes copyright, and then clarifies the essence of copyright law with the clue of how copyright law responds to the challenge caused by communication technology. Based on this, the author puts forward his own views on whether the link directly infringes copyright. The second part of this chapter is the analysis of helpful tort disputes caused by links. First, the author summarizes the relevant laws, regulations and judicial explanations. Combined with relevant cases, this paper discusses how Chinese courts determine whether the establishment of links constitutes helpful infringement. On this basis, the author analyzes the defects of the helpful tort rules, and discusses the feasibility of solving such problems by business model. Just as human society needs not only the law, but also the regulation of other social norms, the problems that appear in the network world also need to be solved in a variety of ways. In the last chapter, the author tries to analyze the copyright infringement caused by link from the angle of ethics and morality, hoping to resolve this kind of complicated contradiction better with the help of another important standard form of human society.
【学位授予单位】：中国政法大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2010
【分类号】：D923.41

【相似文献】