范吕解仇公案再探讨

发布时间：2018-06-14 07:39

本文选题：范仲淹 + 吕夷简　；参考：《历史研究》2013年01期

【摘要】：围绕着如何看待同是仁宗朝名臣的范仲淹与吕夷简的关系,在二人过世之后发生的范吕解仇公案,从北宋到南宋,聚讼纷纭。经过今人绵密研究,可以说大抵尘埃落定,然于欧阳修书写范吕解仇的微言大义,似未有明确揭橥。探究范吕结仇与解仇的经纬,以及踌躇年余才写下范仲淹神道碑铭的欧阳修的心曲,进一步分析南宋考据派与义理派对此事的不同认识,可以看出,于事实,无论是范纯仁所坚持的未解仇,还是欧阳修主张的解仇,都是不同认知层面上的事实。摆脱历史上二人是否解仇的纠结,透过宋代历史的大背景来审视范吕解仇公案以及后世展开的争论,由这一公案引出的历史事实如何认定、历史如何阐释的问题,则或具有广泛意义上的方法论启示。
[Abstract]:Around how to treat the relationship between Fan Zhongyan and Lu Yijian, Fan Zhongyan and Lu Yijian, who were famous officials of Renzong Dynasty, had different lawsuits from the Northern Song Dynasty to the Southern Song Dynasty. After a close study, it can be said that the dust settled, but in the Ouyang Xiu writing fan Lujie enmity of the great meaning, seems to have not been clearly revealed. By probing into Fan Lujie's enmity and understanding of his feud, and by writing the heart song of Ouyang Xiu's inscription on Fan Zhongyan's inscription on the Taoist monument only after years of hesitation, this paper further analyzes the different understandings of textual criticism school and Yili party in the Southern Song Dynasty, and it can be seen that, in fact, Whether it is the unsolved feud that Fan Chun-jen insists on, or the unsolved feud advocated by Ouyang Xiu, it is a fact on different cognitive levels. To get rid of the entanglement between the two people in the history of whether to solve their feuds or not, to examine the public case of Fan Lujie and the disputes that later generations have begun through the background of the history of the Song Dynasty, how to determine the historical facts and how to interpret the history arising from this case. May have a broad sense of methodological enlightenment.
【作者单位】：日本学习院大学东洋文化研究所;
【分类号】：K244

【参考文献】