关于悖论的研究：从社会系统论角度来探讨国际法对跨界水问题的调整作用
发布时间：2022-01-25 06:43
本文是关于“悖论”的研究。与传统观点不同,本文旨在迎合新时代的精神,重新认识悖论的存在和发挥作用的方式。以下是一个悖论的例子:当一位律师想知道“合法性和非法性”这一区别本身是否合法时,尽管他手头上缺乏完整充分信息,他却仍然在这种情况下被迫作出自己的判断。在调整跨界水的国际法规范中最突出的悖论就是由分化的主权观念中所产生的矛盾性期望。这也是为什么我们不难理解,为何国际法学者在学术上经常处于不安的状况中。尤其是考虑到公平合理利用原则,作为国际法学界面对跨界水领域问题所能提供的最为实体性的回应,却未能给解决问题提供任何答案——因为该原则尝试将所有情况涵括在内,结果却是什么情况都无法涵括在内。甚至在某种程度上似乎是这一原则让国际法这一学科产生出“碎片,隔离”（humpty-dumpties）。因为我们日渐发现,法律论证策略逐渐发生以下转变:从确定性向不确定性、从过去到未来,以及从发现认定规则事实到计算各种概率和可能性。尽管法律的形式主义已经发生了以上转变,但是实践中国际法学者很少采用更为合理的方法论来应对上述的不确定性。相反,我们经常看到的是一系列形形色色的自相矛盾和同义反复的法律论证套路,这...
【文章来源】：厦门大学福建省 211工程院校 985工程院校 教育部直属院校
【文章页数】：180 页
【学位级别】：博士
【文章目录】：
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
内容摘要
ABSTRACT
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION AND THESIS OUTLINE
1.1 Mapping out the Structural Problems of Transboundary Waters
1.2 Mapping out the Structural Problems of Law’s Management of Contingency
CHAPTER Ⅱ FIRST-ORDER OBSERVATION: THE DILEMMA OF KOSKENNIMI5S UTOPIANISM AND APOLOGISM
2.1 Introduction of the Key Differences between First and Second-Order observation
2.2 The Utopumist
2.3 The Utopian dilemma
2.4 The Apologist
2.5 The Apologist dilemma
CHAPTER Ⅲ SECOND-ORDER OBSERVATION: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK TO WORK OUT THE REOCCURRING PATTERNS UNDER WHICH INTERNATIONAL LAW MAKES PARADOXES INVISIBLE
3.1 Introduction
3.2 Methodological Background
3.3 Overview of Theoretical Framework
3.4 Theoretical Framework part One: Closure
3.5 Conclusion
CHAPTER Ⅳ SECOND-ORDER OBSERVATION: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK TO WORK OUT THE REOCCURRING PATTERNS UNDER WHICH INTERNATIONAL LAW MIGHT PRODUCTIVELY MAKE USE OF PARADOXES
4.1 Introduction
4.2 Methodological Background
4.3 Overview of Theoretical Framework
4.4 Theoretical Framework part Two:Openness
4.5 Conclusion
CHAPTER V THlRD-ORDER OBSERVATION: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK TO WORK OUT HOW TO STUDY THE FUTURE OF INTEGRATED WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
5.1 Introduction
5.2 Methodological Background
5.3 Overview of Theoretical Framework
5.4 Theoretical Framework part Three: Operative Closure
5.5 Conclusion
CHAPTER Ⅵ REFLECTIONS
BIBLIOGRAPHY
APPENDIX
本文编号：3608074
【文章来源】：厦门大学福建省 211工程院校 985工程院校 教育部直属院校
【文章页数】：180 页
【学位级别】：博士
【文章目录】：
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
内容摘要
ABSTRACT
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION AND THESIS OUTLINE
1.1 Mapping out the Structural Problems of Transboundary Waters
1.2 Mapping out the Structural Problems of Law’s Management of Contingency
CHAPTER Ⅱ FIRST-ORDER OBSERVATION: THE DILEMMA OF KOSKENNIMI5S UTOPIANISM AND APOLOGISM
2.1 Introduction of the Key Differences between First and Second-Order observation
2.2 The Utopumist
2.3 The Utopian dilemma
2.4 The Apologist
2.5 The Apologist dilemma
CHAPTER Ⅲ SECOND-ORDER OBSERVATION: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK TO WORK OUT THE REOCCURRING PATTERNS UNDER WHICH INTERNATIONAL LAW MAKES PARADOXES INVISIBLE
3.1 Introduction
3.2 Methodological Background
3.3 Overview of Theoretical Framework
3.4 Theoretical Framework part One: Closure
3.5 Conclusion
CHAPTER Ⅳ SECOND-ORDER OBSERVATION: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK TO WORK OUT THE REOCCURRING PATTERNS UNDER WHICH INTERNATIONAL LAW MIGHT PRODUCTIVELY MAKE USE OF PARADOXES
4.1 Introduction
4.2 Methodological Background
4.3 Overview of Theoretical Framework
4.4 Theoretical Framework part Two:Openness
4.5 Conclusion
CHAPTER V THlRD-ORDER OBSERVATION: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK TO WORK OUT HOW TO STUDY THE FUTURE OF INTEGRATED WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
5.1 Introduction
5.2 Methodological Background
5.3 Overview of Theoretical Framework
5.4 Theoretical Framework part Three: Operative Closure
5.5 Conclusion
CHAPTER Ⅵ REFLECTIONS
BIBLIOGRAPHY
APPENDIX
本文编号：3608074
本文链接：https://www.wllwen.com/shoufeilunwen/sklbs/3608074.html
