特修斯-副本论证和人工物的同一性
发布时间：2018-11-27 13:48
【摘要】：事物构成部分的变化会引发其同一性问题,副本论证集中体现了此问题的困难之处,因此该论证也成为当代形而上学争论问题的一个平台。关于个人的副本论证是原始版本,分存论和整存论的各自解释策略将会在他们对张三-副本论证的回应中得到展示。更重要的是,要借助副本论证的分析框架来探究单个人工物的同一性问题。基于此,本文将分别重构分存论和整存论处理特修斯-副本论证的各自解释方案,并揭示其不足之处。当此问题得到详细辨明后,将表明整存论在处理特修斯-副本论证时具有更大的说服力。同时,本文还将论证,援引单个人工物的意向实体,特修斯-副本论证难题可能会有一个相对令人满意的解释,人工物的同一性问题因此也有了解决的可能性。
[Abstract]:The change of the composition of things will lead to the problem of identity, and the replica argument embodies the difficulty of this problem, so the argument has become a platform for the contemporary metaphysical debate. As the individual replica argument is the original version, the respective interpretation strategies of the divisional and integrative theories will be shown in their responses to the Chang San-replica argument. More importantly, the identity of a single artifact should be explored with the help of the analytical framework of the replica argument. Based on this, this paper reconstructs the theory of divisional storage and the theory of integral existence respectively to deal with the respective interpretation schemes of Theseus-replica argument, and reveals its shortcomings. When this problem is identified in detail, it will be shown that the whole existence theory is more persuasive in dealing with Theseus-replica argument. At the same time, this paper will prove that there may be a relatively satisfactory explanation for the problem of citing the intended entity of a single artificial object, Theseus and the replica argument, so the problem of identity of the artificial object may also be solved.
【作者单位】： 复旦大学哲学学院;
【基金】：2011年度教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目子项目“分析的技术哲学研究”(11JZD007) 2015年度复旦大学文科项目“分析的技术哲学研究”(WJH3155001)的阶段性成果
【分类号】：B016
本文编号：2360997
[Abstract]:The change of the composition of things will lead to the problem of identity, and the replica argument embodies the difficulty of this problem, so the argument has become a platform for the contemporary metaphysical debate. As the individual replica argument is the original version, the respective interpretation strategies of the divisional and integrative theories will be shown in their responses to the Chang San-replica argument. More importantly, the identity of a single artifact should be explored with the help of the analytical framework of the replica argument. Based on this, this paper reconstructs the theory of divisional storage and the theory of integral existence respectively to deal with the respective interpretation schemes of Theseus-replica argument, and reveals its shortcomings. When this problem is identified in detail, it will be shown that the whole existence theory is more persuasive in dealing with Theseus-replica argument. At the same time, this paper will prove that there may be a relatively satisfactory explanation for the problem of citing the intended entity of a single artificial object, Theseus and the replica argument, so the problem of identity of the artificial object may also be solved.
【作者单位】： 复旦大学哲学学院;
【基金】：2011年度教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目子项目“分析的技术哲学研究”(11JZD007) 2015年度复旦大学文科项目“分析的技术哲学研究”(WJH3155001)的阶段性成果
【分类号】：B016
【相似文献】
相关期刊论文 前5条
1 王德伟;识别人工物是如何可能的?[J];科学学研究;2003年03期
2 王德伟;试论人工物的基本概念[J];自然辩证法研究;2003年05期
3 刘宝杰;;关于技术人工物的两重性理论的述评[J];自然辩证法研究;2011年05期
4 陈凡;徐佳;;论技术人工物的功能归属[J];自然辩证法通讯;2012年03期
5 秦咏红;;可用性及其对技术人工物主客体关系的影响[J];自然辩证法研究;2012年05期
相关会议论文 前1条
1 肖显静;;科学、技术、人工物与环境问题的产生——从技术化科学与科学化技术看[A];全球化视阈中的科技与社会——全国科技与社会（STS）学术年会（2007）论文集[C];2007年
相关博士学位论文 前1条
1 潘恩荣;技术人工物的结构与功能之间的关系[D];浙江大学;2009年
，本文编号：2360997
本文链接：https://www.wllwen.com/zhexuezongjiaolunwen/2360997.html
