马海涛诉李玉兰小产权房纠纷案评析

发布时间：2018-03-08 01:24

本文选题：小产权房　切入点：李玉兰案　出处：《湖南大学》2011年硕士论文　论文类型：学位论文

【摘要】：小产权房是当前社会约定俗称的一个概念,虽然在经济学或者法律上还没有形成一个完整规范的解释,但是却已频繁的出现在国务院办公厅等文件中。小产权房产生于我国特殊的社会背景和特定的法律制度之下,对其是否合法专家学者和相关部门众说纷纭。我国目前关于小产权房问题的立法并未考虑农民利益,使得当前小产权房纠纷日益增多。小产权房纠纷不断出现除了有房产市场规制的不足以外,主要是当前的立法并未考虑到小产权房背后各方利益的博弈及平衡。在现有的小产权房纠纷判决中,虽然法院的处理合乎当前的法律法规,但是判决所依据的法律本身并未充分考虑农民利益,因此这些判决可能存在不合理和值得斟酌的地方。在小产权房的规制上,应以处理好各方利益为出发点,扬利去弊,在承认小产权房合法地位的前提之下,给予必要的限制。在规制中,合理平衡国家利益和集体利益,将法律效力与社会影响相统一,制定合理且严格的土地规划和执行计划,通过完善我国土地流转制度解决我国当前小产权房问题。
[Abstract]:Housing with small property rights is a concept commonly known in the current social convention, although it has not yet formed a complete normative interpretation in economics or law. However, it has frequently appeared in documents such as the General Office of the State Council. Small property houses have emerged under the special social background and specific legal system of our country. There are different opinions on whether it is legal, experts, scholars and relevant departments. At present, the legislation on small property right in our country does not consider the interests of farmers, which makes the dispute of small property house increasing day by day. In addition to the deficiency of the housing market regulation, the current legislation does not take into account the game and balance of the interests of the parties behind the small-property housing. Although the court's treatment is in line with current laws and regulations, the law on which the decisions are based does not by itself take full account of the interests of the farmers, and these decisions may therefore be unreasonable and worth considering. In the regulation of small property houses, we should deal with the interests of all parties as the starting point, promote advantages and disadvantages, and give necessary restrictions on the legal status of small property houses. In the regulation, we should strike a reasonable balance between national interests and collective interests. This paper unifies the legal effect with the social influence, formulates the reasonable and strict land planning and execution plan, and solves the problem of the small property right house in our country by perfecting the land circulation system in our country.
【学位授予单位】：湖南大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2011
【分类号】：D923.2;D922.3;D920.5;F293.3

【相似文献】