论舆论监督、媒体审判与刑事司法独立关系

发布时间：2017-12-28 06:27

本文关键词：论舆论监督、媒体审判与刑事司法独立关系　出处：《南京师大学报(社会科学版)》2016年05期 　论文类型：期刊论文

【摘要】：随着民众参与司法之理念深入人心,媒体对刑事案件报道的透明性增强,一批具有鲜明特点的典型案例群出现在刑法理论研究视野,每一个案均从不同角度展现着公众舆论监督与刑事司法独立性之间的交织与博弈。基于本质属性的相异,舆论监督与刑事司法独立之冲突由来已久,而二者均具有合宪性与合理性依据,良好的制度设计应当在二者之间保持合理张力。通过理论与实务层面的探讨,有必要以促进司法公正为契合点,展现舆论监督的异化过程,归纳媒体审判的形成原因,并于该基础上对舆论监督的原则、监督角色的定位、监督主体的自律等方面提出对策,对司法独立原则的真正含义、司法独立原则的程序价值作出剖析,继而设计出二者之间良性互动的制度框架。
[Abstract]:Along with the people to participate in the judicial concept of the people, media on the transparency of criminal cases reported increased, a number of distinctive characteristics of the typical case group in the criminal law theory research perspective, each case are from different angles show intertwined with the game between public opinion supervision and judicial independence. Based on the difference of essential attributes, the conflict between supervision by public opinion and independence of criminal judicature has existed for a long time, and the two have the basis of constitutionality and rationality. Good institutional design should maintain reasonable tension between the two. Through the discussion of theory and practice, it is necessary to promote justice fit, show the dissimilation process of public supervision, causes induction media trial, and on the basis of the principle of public opinion supervision and supervision role, supervision and self-discipline and puts forward the countermeasures, the true meaning of judicial independence, the value of procedure the principle of the principle of judicial independence to make analysis, and then design the system framework of the benign interaction between the two.
【作者单位】：山西大学法学院;
【分类号】：D924;D926
【正文快照】： 舆论导向影响司法独立的状况具有客观性。一方面,舆论之所以能够对司法独立性产生影响,大致来源于两个层次的原因。首先,人类具有动物性,是丰沛情感与复杂思维的载体,作为刑事司法案件的侦查者、检控者、审判者,对于外界的舆论造势不可能无动于衷,继而在各项司法活动中不免会

【相似文献】