工伤损害赔偿请求权竞合问题研究

发布时间：2018-04-25 17:33

本文选题：工伤损害赔偿 + 请求权　；参考：《吉林财经大学》2014年硕士论文

【摘要】：作为我国社会保障制度体系的重要组成部分，工伤保险制度在法律实践中日益呈现出一种多元化的价值功能，尤其对维护劳动者合法权益和防范、化解用人单位劳动风险，具有重大理论和实践价值。而随着我国社会经济和政治文化的日新月异，工伤保险制度与侵权损害赔偿制度之间凸显出不同程度的竞合。即对于受害人是提请工伤保险给付还是主张侵权损害赔偿的情形，是否可以同时支持，如何处理二者的竞合关系的问题一直困扰着我国法学理论界和实务界。由于我国对于现行劳动法和侵权责任立法存在不全面、不明确、不统一的缺点，使得在法律实践中陷入无法可依的混乱局面，学界对该问题应采用何种处理模式也一直存在着争议。本文试图通过对工伤保险给付与侵权损害赔偿的竞合问题的分析，逐步导出适用于我国现实情况的合理解决模式及立法的完善。本文的写作思路为：第一章，对工伤保险补偿与侵权损害赔偿的竞合关系做一般性分析，明确二者竞合关系的性质。第二章，通过列举国外几种处理模式和相关立法，，全面分析各种处理模式的利弊，为后文我国应采用何种模式提供借鉴和依据；第三章，通过分析我国现有相关立法与司法实践现状，找出我国现有法律的不足和存在争议的问题；第四章，立足我国法律环境，提出笔者对解决上述问题的一些思考和立法建议。
[Abstract]:As an important part of the social security system of our country, the industrial injury insurance system increasingly presents a diversified value function in the legal practice, especially to safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the laborer and guard against, dissolve the labor risk of the employing unit. It has great theoretical and practical value. With the rapid development of social economy and political culture in our country, the competition between industrial injury insurance system and tort compensation system has been highlighted in different degrees. That is to say, whether the victim can support the case of whether the victim asks for payment of injury insurance or claims the compensation for tort damages, and how to deal with the problem of the competing relationship between the two has been puzzling the legal theorists and practitioners in our country all the time. Due to the shortcomings of the existing labor law and tort liability legislation in our country, which are not comprehensive, clear and unified, we are in a chaotic situation which can not be relied upon in the legal practice. There has always been controversy in academic circles about how to deal with this problem. Based on the analysis of the competing problems between the payment of industrial injury insurance and the compensation for tort damages, this paper tries to gradually derive the reasonable solution model and the perfection of legislation applicable to the reality of our country. The main ideas of this paper are as follows: the first chapter makes a general analysis of the relationship between compensation for industrial injury insurance and compensation for tort damages, and clarifies the nature of the relationship between the two. The second chapter, by enumerating several kinds of foreign processing modes and relevant legislation, comprehensively analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of various treatment modes, and provides the reference and basis for the following articles about what kind of model should be adopted in our country; chapter three, By analyzing the current situation of legislation and judicial practice in our country, we find out the deficiency of our existing law and the controversial problems. Chapter four, based on the legal environment of our country, puts forward some thoughts and legislative suggestions to solve the above problems.
【学位授予单位】：吉林财经大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2014
【分类号】：D923;D922.55

【相似文献】