司法与仲裁关系之探索

发布时间：2018-04-04 02:17

本文选题：司法　切入点：仲裁　出处：《上海交通大学》2007年硕士论文

【摘要】： 司法与仲裁制度作为我国民商法体系中的重要组成部分,在和谐社会主义建设中起到了化解市场经济主体在经济活动中发生的利益冲突,保护当事人合法的民事权益,维护社会的经济秩序和生活秩序,保障市场经济的健康发展等积极作用。理论与实践,无论从哪个层面出发,司法与仲裁二者之间都存在着深刻的渊源。体现在仲裁的立法中,就表现为司法对仲裁的支持与协助,以及司法对仲裁的审查与控制。在形式上,司法对仲裁的参与制式既有支持,也有限制。司法对仲裁的支持使得仲裁的进行有了国家强制力的维护;同时,司法对仲裁的限制又给予了仲裁公正性的保障。本文通过深入审视与分析司法与仲裁之间的关系,力争在理念上形成更为深刻的认识,以求能够更好地平衡二者的地位。这在实现公正与效率并重的价值标准、实现司法介入但无干预的基本原则等方面具有一定的理论意义。在寻求最大限度发挥仲裁优势与作用的模式同时,又不削弱司法应有的权威,使仲裁与司法形成相辅相成、又互相牵制,在一定范围内开展竞争的态势。在实践中,司法和仲裁良性关系的形成及贯彻状况更是对国家经济和法制环境有着至关重要的影响力,完善而开放的司法与仲裁的关系体系可以让我国在国际经济竞争中取得优势地位,增强我国对外国贸易伙伴和投资者的吸引力。首先,本文对司法与仲裁的关系进行探源。从理论层面的高度对司法与仲裁进行概述,阐明其概念、性质、特点、历史发展以及相互存在的千丝万缕的联系。其次,在对司法与仲裁两组问题明析的基础上,延续历史的脉络,进一步深入阐释当代法制社会中,司法与仲裁真正形成的关系:支持与监督。同时从支持与监督两个方面进行剖析,力争全面解读二者的联系。然后,综合借鉴当代国际社会中有代表性的国家的仲裁制度,对司法与仲裁关系的相互作用进行世界范围内的比较和借鉴。最后,落实在当代我国法制建设的社会进程中,对我国法律系统中的司法与仲裁关系的积极以及消极方面进行思考和分析,对我国司法与仲裁关系的完善提出一点建议。
[Abstract]:As an important part of the civil and commercial law system of our country, the judicial and arbitration system has played an important role in resolving the conflicts of interest in the economic activities of the main body of the market economy and protecting the legitimate civil rights and interests of the parties in the construction of harmonious socialism.Maintain social economic order and life order, ensure the healthy development of market economy and other positive roles.Theory and practice, no matter from which level, there is a profound origin between judicature and arbitration.In the legislation of arbitration, the judicial support and assistance to arbitration, as well as the judicial review and control of arbitration.In form, the judicial system of participation in arbitration has both support and limitations.The support of the judicature to the arbitration makes the arbitration have the national compulsory force, at the same time, the restriction of the judicature to the arbitration gives the guarantee of the arbitration fairness.By examining and analyzing the relationship between judicature and arbitration in depth, this paper tries to form a deeper understanding on the idea, in order to balance the status of the two better.It has certain theoretical significance in realizing the value standard of justice and efficiency, and realizing the basic principle of judicial intervention but no intervention.At the same time, it does not weaken the authority of the judicature, make arbitration and judicature complement each other, restrain each other, and develop the situation of competition in a certain range.In practice, the formation and implementation of the benign relationship between judicature and arbitration has a vital influence on the national economic and legal environment.The perfect and open relationship system between judicature and arbitration can make our country gain advantages in the international economic competition and enhance our attraction to foreign trading partners and investors.First of all, this paper explores the relationship between judicature and arbitration.From the perspective of theory, this paper summarizes the concept, nature, characteristics, historical development and interrelationship between judicature and arbitration.Secondly, on the basis of analyzing the two groups of problems of judicature and arbitration, this paper continues the historical context, and further explains the real relationship between judicature and arbitration in the contemporary society of legal system: support and supervision.At the same time, from the support and supervision of the two aspects of analysis, strive to fully understand the relationship between the two.Then, draw lessons from the arbitration system of representative countries in the contemporary international society, compare and draw lessons from the interaction between judicature and arbitration in the world.Finally, in the social process of the construction of legal system in contemporary China, the author thinks and analyzes the positive and negative aspects of the relationship between judicature and arbitration in the legal system of our country, and puts forward some suggestions for the perfection of the relationship between judicature and arbitration in our country.
【学位授予单位】：上海交通大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2007
【分类号】：D925.7;D926

【引证文献】