完善指定居所监视居住制度研究

发布时间：2018-03-06 23:29

本文选题：指定居所　切入点：监视居住　出处：《华东政法大学》2014年硕士论文　论文类型：学位论文

【摘要】：2013年1月1日起施行的《刑事诉讼法》对我国的强制措施部分进行了修改，而本次修改最为令人们关注的是在第72条规定了指定居所监视居住制度。在监视居住制度处于一个备而不用的境地，要求废除监视居住制度意愿强烈的背景下，指定居所监视居住制度被写入了《刑事诉讼法》，无疑再次引发了人们对监视居住、指定居所监视居住制度存废的争论。研读新《刑事诉讼法》强制措施部分的规定，我们对于指定居所监视居住制度的设置存在太多的疑问，无怪乎其一出台就听到了反对的声音。指定居所监视居住是第六种强制措施，还是监视居住的特殊形式，，人们对此有不同的观点；指定居所监视居住具非羁押性的属性，还是具羁押替代性的属性，人们对此有不同的理解；指定居所监视居住应当如何适用，人们也有不同的看法。如今，指定居所监视居住制度在质疑声中已施行一年有余，实务中指定居所监视居住制度也正如人们所预料的，与监视居住制度一样处于一个备而不用的境地。为什么不适用指定居所监视居住，究其原因是人们对指定居所监视居住制度存有疑惑，指定居所监视居住制度先天畸形，人们担心指定居所监视居住制度会成为变相羁押的合法外衣，担忧指定居所监视居住制度会侵害犯罪嫌疑人、被告人的权益，种种担忧、担心使得指定居所监视居住制度成为了一纸空文。但一项制度的出台必有其意义，指定居所监视居住制度也必然有其存在的合理性和必要性。本文试从指定居所监视居住制度的性质、适用现状、监视居住制度体系的架构出发，结合实务中所接触的案例，比较域外现行的类似指定居所监视居住制度，对我国指定居所监视居住制度应如何完善进行研究。
[Abstract]:The Criminal procedure Law, which has been in force since January 1st 2013, has partly amended the compulsory measures in China. What is of most concern to people in this amendment is the stipulation of the designated residence surveillance residence system in Article 72. In a situation where the surveillance residence system is in a situation where there is no need to do so, there is a strong desire to abolish the surveillance residence system. The system of designated residence surveillance has been written into the Criminal procedure Law, which undoubtedly has once again triggered a debate about the retention or abolition of the system of supervised residence and designated residence. Study the provisions of the compulsory measures in the new Code of Criminal procedure. We have so many doubts about the establishment of a designated residence monitoring system that no wonder we have heard opposition from one of them. Is designated residence surveillance a compulsory measure of 6th kinds or a special form of residence surveillance? People have different views on this; people have different understandings as to whether a designated residence monitoring residence has a non-custodial nature or an alternative nature of custody; and how a designated residence monitoring residence should be applied. People also have different views. Nowadays, the designated residence monitoring residence system has been in place for more than a year in the midst of questioning, and in practice, the designated residence monitoring residence system is as expected. The reason why the designated residence surveillance system is not applicable is that people have doubts about the designated residence monitoring residence system, which is congenital malformation. People are worried that the designated residence surveillance residence system will become a legal cover for disguised detention. People worry that the designated residence monitoring housing system will infringe on the rights and interests of criminal suspects and defendants, and all kinds of worries. Fear has made the system of designated residence surveillance a dead letter. But the introduction of a system must make sense. This paper tries to analyze the nature of the system, the current situation of its application, the framework of the system, and the cases it has come into contact with. In this paper, the author makes a study on how to perfect the system of designated residence surveillance in our country.
【学位授予单位】：华东政法大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2014
【分类号】：D925.2

【相似文献】