经济政策对法院裁判思路的影响研究——以涉外贴牌生产案件为素材

发布时间：2018-06-30 05:19

本文选题：涉外贴牌生产 + 商标侵权　；参考：《法制与社会发展》2013年05期

【摘要】：在涉外贴牌生产案件中,法院早期严格遵循法条主义思路所做出的判决,其内容虽然合法,但"社会效果"不佳。以国内经济形势的变化为契机,法院开始借助多种司法技术改变裁判思路,从而使司法审判服务于中国经济发展的大局。法院裁判思路的变化过程,实际上也是政策进入裁判的过程,这一过程充分展示了经济政策对司法裁判的客观影响。作为一个经验事实,政策进入裁判固然有其合理性所在,但也可能引发一系列负面影响。有鉴于此,政策进入裁判必须通过法治"轨道"上的政策转介机制,并借助恰当的司法技术加以实现。尤其是在司法技术的运用上,要避免出现方法论上的错误,更不能一味地追求裁判结果的社会妥当性而忽视成文法规则的存在。
[Abstract]:In the case of foreign brand production, the early judgment made by the court strictly follows the idea of legalism, although its content is legal, its "social effect" is not good. Taking the change of the domestic economic situation as the turning point, the court began to change the judgment mentality with the help of various judicial techniques, thus making the judicial trial serve the overall situation of China's economic development. The changing process of the thinking of the court judgment is actually the process of the policy entering the judgment, which fully demonstrates the objective influence of the economic policy on the judicial decision. As an empirical fact, the policy entry judgment has its rationality, but it may also lead to a series of negative effects. In view of this, the policy entering the adjudication must be realized through the policy referral mechanism on the track of rule of law and with the help of appropriate judicial techniques. Especially in the application of judicial technology, we should avoid the errors in methodology, nor should we blindly pursue the social appropriateness of the adjudication result and ignore the existence of written law rules.
【作者单位】：东南大学法学院;
【基金】：中央高校基本科研业务费专项基金资助(SKCX20130035)
【分类号】：D926.2

【相似文献】