组合与收敛结构之分的新标准——弗里曼方案评析
发布时间：2018-08-28 12:27
【摘要】：组合结构与收敛结构的区分是非形式逻辑领域的一个核心问题,是论证结构研究的重点和难点,一直以来都没有得到合理解决。2011年美国学者弗里曼在反思已有区分方案的基础上,提出了以“中介要素”为标准的解决方案。该方案揭示了既有方案存在的问题及其错误根源,通过语法标准的设立为困扰学界已久的组合与收敛结构的区分问题提供了一条新的解决思路。该方案的不足在于无法合理解释收敛结构中推论规则的识别问题,而且,有时还会导致违反直觉的结论。
[Abstract]:The distinction between combinatorial structure and convergent structure is a core problem in the field of informal logic, which is the focus and difficulty in the research of argumentation structure. In 2011, American scholar Freeman, on the basis of reflecting on the existing differentiation schemes, put forward a solution based on "intermediary elements". The scheme reveals the problems existing in the existing schemes and the root causes of their errors, and provides a new way to solve the problem of distinguishing existing schemes from convergent structures through the establishment of grammatical standards. The shortcoming of this scheme is that it can not reasonably explain the problem of identifying inference rules in convergence structure, and sometimes it will lead to counterintuitive conclusions.
【作者单位】： 中国政法大学哲学系;
【分类号】：N031
本文编号：2209399
[Abstract]:The distinction between combinatorial structure and convergent structure is a core problem in the field of informal logic, which is the focus and difficulty in the research of argumentation structure. In 2011, American scholar Freeman, on the basis of reflecting on the existing differentiation schemes, put forward a solution based on "intermediary elements". The scheme reveals the problems existing in the existing schemes and the root causes of their errors, and provides a new way to solve the problem of distinguishing existing schemes from convergent structures through the establishment of grammatical standards. The shortcoming of this scheme is that it can not reasonably explain the problem of identifying inference rules in convergence structure, and sometimes it will lead to counterintuitive conclusions.
【作者单位】： 中国政法大学哲学系;
【分类号】：N031
【相似文献】
相关会议论文 前1条
1 庄孔韶;;谈田野工作的质量问题——试试阅读弗里曼[A];共识（2009春刊01）[C];2009年
相关重要报纸文章 前4条
1 董铭;《遗愿清单》：带不走的都是梦[N];东方航空报;2008年
2 徐翼;中国人，，为你的国家骄傲吧[N];中华工商时报;2003年
3 李良勇;游说团体搅局,美情报高官人选弃官[N];新华每日电讯;2009年
4 中共杭州市委党校副教授 周旭霞;建设创新型城市是历史的必然选择[N];杭州日报;2010年
相关硕士学位论文 前2条
1 孙莹;玛丽·弗里曼作品的生态女性主义解读[D];北京语言大学;2009年
2 张霞;熊彼特与弗里曼的创新思想及其比较研究[D];郑州大学;2010年
本文编号：2209399
本文链接：https://www.wllwen.com/shekelunwen/ljx/2209399.html
