图尔敏论证模式研究

  本文关键词：图尔敏论证模式研究，由笔耕文化传播整理发布。

　　论文标题图尔敏论证模式研究
Chaos and Harmony An Investigation on the Writing Features of Suggestion
论文作者莫晓红
论文导师傅坚,论文学位硕士,论文专业逻辑学
论文单位华南师范大学,点击次数0,论文页数53页File Size1903k
2004-06-01图尔敏;论证模式;有效性;领域依存性
Toulmin;the model of argument;validity;field-dependence
本论文主要研究S．E．图尔敏的论证模式。图尔敏在与法学类比的基础上，，提出了一个由主张、资料(根据)、正当理由、支援、限定词和反驳等六个功能要素构成的过程性模式。 本文分为五个部分。第一部分介绍了图尔敏论证模式产生的背景。第二部分介绍了图尔敏论证模式的构造要素和基本形式。第三部分把图尔敏论证模式与传统论证模式进行比较，指出图尔敏论证模式对传统论证模式的突破。第四部分介绍理论界对图尔敏论证模式的反应。第五部分阐述了图尔敏论证模式的理论和实践意义，并就模式中的重要要素“正当理由”提出自己的一些看法，最后在指出该模式不足的基础上，发展了该模式。
This paper is mainly to study S.E.Toulmin"s model of argument. On the basis of an analogy between logic and jurisprudence, Toulmin brings up a procedural model, which is composed of six functional elements: claim, data (ground), warrant, backing, qualifier and rebuttal.The paper can be divided into five parts. The first part introduces the background of Toulmin"s model of argument. The second part introduces the six elements and the basic forms of Toulmin"s model of argument. The third part compares Toulmin"s model of argument with traditional model of argument, then it indicates the breakthroughs of Toulmin"s model of argument. The fourth part introduces the responses to Toulmin"s model of argument in the academic circle. The fifth part illustrates the theoretical and practical meanings of Touimin"s model of argument, and it also explores some opinions about warrant, which is an important element. Finally, on the basis of exposing the deficiency of Toulmin"s model of argument, it extends the model.

  本文关键词：图尔敏论证模式研究，由笔耕文化传播整理发布。