温和语境论视阈下的认识模态句研究
发布时间：2023-10-12 04:44
作为语言哲学研究的核心论题,意义问题历久弥新、广受瞩目。为了探求语言的意义,人们一直致力于确定句子的真值条件以判断句子所表达命题之真伪。在此过程中,我们不难发现一些命题的真值似乎更加难以确定。譬如,我们几乎可以不假思索地判断“孔子是中国最伟大的圣人之一”这一句子的真伪。可是要判断“孔子可能是中国最伟大的圣人之一”的真伪却并非易事。究其原因,前者仅关涉某可能世界存在的事实,而后者由于包含认识模态词“可能”而关涉某种可能性。这类包含认识模态词的句子(认识模态句,简称EMSs)之真值实难判断,一方面由于其字面意义与现实世界和个人背景提供的相关信息紧密相连、难以分割,另一方面由于我们在交流过程中互相交换并随时更新自身持有的思想而导致这些信息随之改变。因此,EMSs之真值不仅相关于真实世界的现实情况,而且与某人的认知信息相关联。问题在于:与谁的认知信息关联?言者?听者?旁观者?还是其他什么人?这个看似简单的问题业已引起了哲学家、语言学家和逻辑学家的广泛关注和激烈争论。就语言哲学界而言,最小论者、语境论者、表达论者、永恒论者和相对论者根据各自语义学与语用学分界的不同理解,对EMSs做出了不同的阐释...
【文章页数】：303 页
【学位级别】：博士
【文章目录】：
Acknowledgements
Abstract
摘要
List of Abbreviations
Chapter1 Introduction
1.1 Rationale
1.2 Significance of the Study
1.3 Objectives and Questions
1.4 Methodology Preliminaries
1.5 Organizational Structure of the Dissertation
Chapter2 Literature Review:How to Judge the Truth Value of EMSs?
2.1 Previous Studies on Moderate Contextualism
2.1.1 Survey of the"Border War"
2.1.2 Contextualism and Competitive Doctrines
2.1.3 Moderate Contextualism
2.2 Previous Studies on EMs and EMSs
2.2.1 Modals and Epistemic Modals
2.2.2 Minimalist Construal of EMSs
2.2.3 Contextualist Solutions to EMSs
2.2.4 Relativist Solutions to EMSs
2.2.5 Alternative Accounts of EMSs
2.2.6 Taking Stock:Clarifications and Distinctions
Chapter3 Semantic Content of EMSs:Changeable or Stable?
3.1 Content:Dichotomized Classification
3.1.1 Rethinking Kaplan
3.1.2 Reconsidering Dummett
3.1.3 Reexamination of Bidimensional Model of Content
3.2 Content:Multi-Scaled Classification
3.2.1 Bach's Tridimensional Sorting
3.2.2 Recanati's Basic Triad
3.2.3 Reconsideration of Triad Models of Content
3.3 Syncretic Model of Content:Four Levels
3.3.1 A Four-Level Model of Meaning
3.3.2 Variable Semantic Content of EMSs
Chapter4 Faultless Disagreement on EMSs:To Be or Not To Be?
4.1 FD:Relativist Treatments
4.1.1 FD:Definition and Justification
4.1.2 Account of FD:Moderate Relativism
4.1.3 Account of Disagreement:Assessment-Sensitivity Relativism
4.2 FD:A Moderate Contextualist Treatment
4.2.1"Faultless"and"Disagreement"
4.2.1.1 Fecility of"Faultless"
4.2.1.2 Variants of"Disagreement"
4.2.2 FD:From the Perspective of Moderate Contextualism
4.3 Faultless Disagreement on EMSs:An Illusion
Chapter5 Context of EMSs:Use,Assessment,or Both?
5.1 Notions of Context
5.1.1 Context:From Non-Philosophical Perspectives
5.1.2 Context:From Perspectives of Philosophy of Language
5.2 Three Dimensions of Context
5.2.1 Literal Context
5.2.2 Situational Context
5.2.2.1 Conversational Setting
5.2.2.2 Attained Cognizance
5.2.2.3 Encyclopedic Knowledge
5.2.3 Supplemental Context
5.3 Context of EMSs:An MC Framework
5.3.1 Context of Use vs.Context of Assessment
5.3.2 Contextual Effects on EMSs
Chapter6 An MC Model of EMSs:Contextual Intrusion into Truth-Conditional Content?
6.1 Three Models of EMSs
6.1.1 Contextualist Model
6.1.2 Relativist Model
6.1.3 Expressivist Model
6.2 An MC Model of EMSs
6.2.1 EMSs:Expressing Propositions or Attitudes?
6.2.2 A Model of EMSs:Two Phases
6.2.2.1 Pre-Assessment Phase of EMSs
6.2.2.2 Post-Assessment Phase of EMSs
6.2.2.3 Two Phases:Divergence and Combination
6.2.3 A Model of EMSs:An MC Perspective
6.2.4 S/P Interface in EMSs
6.3 Context-Dependence:A Gradient Continuum
6.3.1 Two Dimensions of Context-Dependence
6.3.2 Context-Dependence of EMSs
6.4 The MC Model of EMSs:Applicable to Other Problem Cases?
6.4.1 The Puzzle of PPT:Matter of Taste
6.4.2 Application of the MC Model to PPTs
Chapter7 Conclusion
7.1 Major Findings
7.2 Implications
7.3 Limitations
7.4 Suggestions for Future Studies
Bibliography
作者攻读博士学位期间科研成果情况
本文编号：3853475
【文章页数】：303 页
【学位级别】：博士
【文章目录】：
Acknowledgements
Abstract
摘要
List of Abbreviations
Chapter1 Introduction
1.1 Rationale
1.2 Significance of the Study
1.3 Objectives and Questions
1.4 Methodology Preliminaries
1.5 Organizational Structure of the Dissertation
Chapter2 Literature Review:How to Judge the Truth Value of EMSs?
2.1 Previous Studies on Moderate Contextualism
2.1.1 Survey of the"Border War"
2.1.2 Contextualism and Competitive Doctrines
2.1.3 Moderate Contextualism
2.2 Previous Studies on EMs and EMSs
2.2.1 Modals and Epistemic Modals
2.2.2 Minimalist Construal of EMSs
2.2.3 Contextualist Solutions to EMSs
2.2.4 Relativist Solutions to EMSs
2.2.5 Alternative Accounts of EMSs
2.2.6 Taking Stock:Clarifications and Distinctions
Chapter3 Semantic Content of EMSs:Changeable or Stable?
3.1 Content:Dichotomized Classification
3.1.1 Rethinking Kaplan
3.1.2 Reconsidering Dummett
3.1.3 Reexamination of Bidimensional Model of Content
3.2 Content:Multi-Scaled Classification
3.2.1 Bach's Tridimensional Sorting
3.2.2 Recanati's Basic Triad
3.2.3 Reconsideration of Triad Models of Content
3.3 Syncretic Model of Content:Four Levels
3.3.1 A Four-Level Model of Meaning
3.3.2 Variable Semantic Content of EMSs
Chapter4 Faultless Disagreement on EMSs:To Be or Not To Be?
4.1 FD:Relativist Treatments
4.1.1 FD:Definition and Justification
4.1.2 Account of FD:Moderate Relativism
4.1.3 Account of Disagreement:Assessment-Sensitivity Relativism
4.2 FD:A Moderate Contextualist Treatment
4.2.1"Faultless"and"Disagreement"
4.2.1.1 Fecility of"Faultless"
4.2.1.2 Variants of"Disagreement"
4.2.2 FD:From the Perspective of Moderate Contextualism
4.3 Faultless Disagreement on EMSs:An Illusion
Chapter5 Context of EMSs:Use,Assessment,or Both?
5.1 Notions of Context
5.1.1 Context:From Non-Philosophical Perspectives
5.1.2 Context:From Perspectives of Philosophy of Language
5.2 Three Dimensions of Context
5.2.1 Literal Context
5.2.2 Situational Context
5.2.2.1 Conversational Setting
5.2.2.2 Attained Cognizance
5.2.2.3 Encyclopedic Knowledge
5.2.3 Supplemental Context
5.3 Context of EMSs:An MC Framework
5.3.1 Context of Use vs.Context of Assessment
5.3.2 Contextual Effects on EMSs
Chapter6 An MC Model of EMSs:Contextual Intrusion into Truth-Conditional Content?
6.1 Three Models of EMSs
6.1.1 Contextualist Model
6.1.2 Relativist Model
6.1.3 Expressivist Model
6.2 An MC Model of EMSs
6.2.1 EMSs:Expressing Propositions or Attitudes?
6.2.2 A Model of EMSs:Two Phases
6.2.2.1 Pre-Assessment Phase of EMSs
6.2.2.2 Post-Assessment Phase of EMSs
6.2.2.3 Two Phases:Divergence and Combination
6.2.3 A Model of EMSs:An MC Perspective
6.2.4 S/P Interface in EMSs
6.3 Context-Dependence:A Gradient Continuum
6.3.1 Two Dimensions of Context-Dependence
6.3.2 Context-Dependence of EMSs
6.4 The MC Model of EMSs:Applicable to Other Problem Cases?
6.4.1 The Puzzle of PPT:Matter of Taste
6.4.2 Application of the MC Model to PPTs
Chapter7 Conclusion
7.1 Major Findings
7.2 Implications
7.3 Limitations
7.4 Suggestions for Future Studies
Bibliography
作者攻读博士学位期间科研成果情况
本文编号：3853475
本文链接：https://www.wllwen.com/shoufeilunwen/rwkxbs/3853475.html
