著作权与物权之关系的协调与立法完善

发布时间：2018-01-20 02:50

  本文关键词： 著作权 物权 《著作权法》第18条 送审稿第22条　出处：《苏州大学》2015年硕士论文　论文类型：学位论文

【摘要】：视觉艺术作品原件的转让会导致作品的著作权人和原件物权人分离为不同主体,这就使得协调两者的关系进而协调两者之间的利益成为亟待解决的问题。本文以我国《著作权法》第18条和送审稿第22条的比较为切入点,加之钱钟书手稿书信案和赤壁之战壁画案的司法判决实践,梳理著作权人和物权人关系协调的现状,考察国外相关的立法与实践,进而提出对著作权和物权之关系协调的立法完善建议。全文共分为五个部分。第一部分是著作权与物权之关系的理论基础考察,主要分析了作品与作品载体的关系以及视觉艺术作品的著作权与原件物权的关系,并对《著作权法》第18条的合理性进行了论证。第二部分是著作权与物权之关系处理的法律困境,包括适用客体的延伸需求和《著作权法》第18条在实践中的适用困境,得出第18条有何不足之处。第三部分是著作权与物权之关系的法条完善现状,主要以草案送审稿第22条为基础进行论证。第四部分是著作权与物权之关系处理的国外立法例考察,对德国、日本和美国在著作权和物权关系处理上值得借鉴的地方进行了分析。第五部分为著作权与物权之关系协调的立法完善建议,是笔者在以上四部分的论证基础上对理论和制度的总结思考。
[Abstract]:The transfer of the original of the visual art works will lead to the separation of the copyright owner and the original owner into different subjects. This makes the coordination of the relationship between the two and then to coordinate the interests between the two becomes a problem to be solved. This article is based on the comparison between Article 18 of the copyright Law and Article 22 of the draft. In addition, the judicial judgment practice of Qian Zhongshu's manuscripts letter case and Chibi War murals case combs the current situation of the coordination between copyright owner and real right owner, and inspects the relevant legislation and practice abroad. Then the author puts forward some suggestions to perfect the relationship between copyright and real right. The whole paper is divided into five parts. The first part is the theoretical basis of the relationship between copyright and real right. It mainly analyzes the relationship between the work and the carrier of the work and the relationship between the copyright of the visual art work and the real right of the original. And the rationality of Article 18 of copyright Law is demonstrated. The second part is the legal dilemma of dealing with the relationship between copyright and real right. Including the extension needs of the applicable object and the dilemma of the application of Article 18 in practice, the author draws the conclusion of the deficiency of Article 18. The third part is the perfect status of the relationship between copyright and real right. The 4th part is the investigation of foreign legislation on the relationship between copyright and real right. Japan and the United States in the handling of copyright and real right relations are worth learning from the analysis of the place. 5th part of the copyright and property rights to coordinate the relationship between the legislative recommendations for improvement. On the basis of the above-mentioned four-part argumentation, the author summarizes the theory and system.
【学位授予单位】：苏州大学
【学位级别】：硕士
【学位授予年份】：2015
【分类号】：D923.41

【参考文献】

中国期刊全文数据库 前2条

1 熊文聪;;知识产权权利冲突:命题的反思与检讨[J];法制与社会发展;2013年03期

2 李翔;曹雅晶;;失落的展览权——从“钱钟书书信拍卖案”谈起,兼论《著作权法》第十八条之理解[J];中国版权;2014年04期

，

本文编号：1446548